ON THE TWELFTH DAY OF CHRISTMAS: Years after Maggie and Mitch bonded over their mutual love for Christmas during a road trip, they run into each other again; only this time Mitch has lost his love for the holiday, after a string of bad luck. Determined to remind him of his Christmas spirit, Maggie sends him a Secret Santa gift, telling him to do a Christmas task. Mitch is a talk show radio DJ and shares his Secret Santa experience with his listeners. As the gifts gain notoriety from the news, Maggie's boss sends her to document Mitch following through on all the tasks. Now in the story herself, Maggie must find a way to keep it under wraps, that she is Mitch's secret Santa. LOVE ALWAYS, SANTA: Celia Banks has given her whole life to seven-year-old daughter. After losing her husband three years ago, Celia has also given up on love...but Lilly doesn't want her mother to spend another holiday season alone. She decides to send a letter to Santa, Inc., a service that answers children's North Pole bound mail, wishing for her mum to be happy again. When struggling children's author Jake Platt ('Santa') receives Lilly's letter, he is inspired to write for the first time in years. Once Celia reads Jake's heartfelt response, the two begin an old-fashioned correspondence and fall more in love with each letter, just in time for Christmas. MY CHRISTMAS LOVE: As a hopeless romantic, Cynthia is crushed when her boyfriend breaks up with her right before the holidays. With love no longer an option for her, she coaxes her friend Liam to go home with her for her sister's Christmas wedding. When she starts receiving all the gifts from 'The 12 Days of Christmas' at her door, she thinks one of her exes might be trying to get back together with her. Now, Cynthia is determined to discover who is behind this epic romantic gesture, a gesture so elaborate that it must mean true love. The search proves to be more arduous than she first expected and when all hope seems lost, she discovers that true love might have been standing in front of her the whole time. A CINDERELLA CHRISTMAS: Angie works had to run her uncle's event planning business, while her cousin Candace takes all of the credit. In exchange for ownership of the business, Angie helps Candace get an invitation to the famous Christmasquerade Ball being held by wealthy bachelor Nicholas Carmichael. But when Candace gets sick, Angie puts on the mask, goes in her place and has an immediate connection with Nicholas. When he vows to marry the mysterious woman from the Ball, Angie finds herself torn between either losing the business she's worked so hard for or losing the love of her life.